I do not really see the point of the debate over neoliberalism.
The critics seem to suggest that market liberalization, privatization and deregulation are evil. The proponents, on the other hand, if this subhuman species exists, glorify them as the miraculous policies that cure all the economic ills of the world.
The truth is, of course, as always, more complicated than this kind of caricatures. It is true that market liberalization, for example, may wreak havoc a market. But, done right, it can do wonders. Just look at what happen to airfares in the past decade; or, how easy you change your wireless phone provider just because you do not like the color of the recent poster of your current carrier.
I think it would be better if the presidential candidates’ economists stop this amateurish philosophical bickering. Instead, they should start talking about real problems that matter to real people, like how to help small coffee farmers help themselves, or how to expedite the process of setting up a firm.
I am not a political analyst; so, I do not know whether this move would win more votes. But, the last time I checked, most Indonesians are either small farmers or workers in informal sectors.
Their sheer numbers – these are, I think, reasons enough to talk to them.